If you’re moving from almost anywhere else, Florida homeowners insurance will surprise you — in structure, not just price. Here’s what’s genuinely different, so you can shop like a local.
The pieces of the puzzle
- Hurricane deductible: not a flat number but a percentage of your dwelling coverage — commonly 2%. On a $500k dwelling, that’s a $10,000 deductible for named-storm damage, separate from your regular deductible.
- Flood is always separate. No homeowners policy covers flood or storm surge. See the flood zone guide.
- Roof age rules everything. Many carriers won’t write a new policy on a shingle roof older than ~15 years, and an aging roof raises premiums sharply. When buying, the roof’s age is an insurance question first and a maintenance question second.
- Four-point inspection: for older homes, insurers want a report on roof, electrical, plumbing, and HVAC before they’ll bind coverage. Budget for it and schedule early.
- Wind mitigation inspection: the good news. Documented hurricane features — roof straps, impact windows, sealed roof deck — earn real, mandated discounts. This $100-ish inspection often pays for itself many times over.
Shopping smart
- Use an independent agent who writes with multiple Florida carriers — the market shifts constantly and last year’s cheapest carrier may not be writing new policies this year.
- Quote during your home-buying inspection period. Insurability problems (roof, panel type, polybutylene plumbing) are negotiating items — but only before you close.
- Ask about Citizens (the state-backed insurer of last resort) only after exhausting the private market; it comes with its own rules and assessments.
- Impact windows and a newer roof aren’t just safety — they’re recurring dividends in premium savings and resale value.
For condo buyers
The building’s master policy covers the structure; you carry an HO-6 policy for your interior, contents, and liability — dramatically cheaper than house insurance. But verify what the master policy actually covers (“walls-in” vs “studs-in”) and whether the association’s coverage and reserves are adequate; gaps land on unit owners as assessments.
Rule of thumb for every SWFL purchase: no offer without an insurance reality check. I flag the insurance red flags — roof age, zone, panel type — before my clients write, not after.